The difference is about what happens to the income. It isn't about how much the fund earns. That one point clears up most of the confusion.
The short answer
- Accumulating: the income stays in the fund and keeps working.
- Distributing: the income lands in your cash account.
- A payout is not extra return. It comes out of the fund's value on the payout day.
- Germany taxes distributions when they're paid. Accumulating funds can trigger a yearly Vorabpauschale instead. Both use the same partial exemption and allowance.
- Neither version is better for everyone.
Picture a pot
Think of the fund as a pot. When the companies inside pay dividends, an accumulating fund puts the money back into the pot. A distributing fund hands it to you, and the pot gets smaller by exactly that amount.
Same fund, three outcomes
Two hypothetical investors put €10,000 into the same ETF and add €200 a month for 20 years. The fund returns 6% a year in total, before a 0.2% fund cost. In the distributing class, 2% of that is paid out each year.
| Accumulating | Distributing, payouts reinvested | Distributing, payouts kept as cash | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fund value after 20 years | €119,378 | €119,378 | €90,543 |
| Cash taken out | — | — | €18,978 |
| Total | €119,378 | €119,378 | €109,521 |
Before tax and trading costs, reinvesting the payouts gives exactly the same result as accumulating. Keeping the payouts as cash leaves less in the fund, because that money stopped growing inside it. The figures come from our calculator and are illustrations, not forecasts.
Want the nerdy details?The rules, the exact numbers and the edge cases. Open it whenever you're curious.- How Germany taxes each version
How Germany taxes each version
German investment tax law treats both share classes under the same system. Fund income comes in three forms: distributions, the Vorabpauschale and gains on sale. 2
- Distributing: the payout is taxable in the year you receive it. For an equity fund, 30% of it is tax-free (Teilfreistellung), and your yearly allowance (Sparer-Pauschbetrag) applies. 34
- Accumulating: nothing is paid out, but a yearly Vorabpauschale can be taxed. It's based on a government interest rate and capped by the fund's actual rise in value. In weak years it can be zero. 5
- When you sell: gains are taxed for both. Vorabpauschalen taxed in earlier years are deducted from the gain, so they aren't taxed twice. 6
Germany's consumer advice centres put it simply: for tax purposes, distributing and accumulating ETFs are treated similarly. 1 Which one leads to less tax over many years depends on your allowance, the yearly Basiszins and how long you hold. There's no general answer.
Day-to-day differences
| Topic | Accumulating | Distributing |
|---|---|---|
| Effort | Nothing to do | Payouts arrive as cash; you decide what to do with them |
| Reinvesting | Automatic, inside the fund | Manual or with a savings plan; may cost a fee |
| Cash flow | None until you sell | Regular payouts |
| Using your allowance | Mainly through the Vorabpauschale | Payouts can use the allowance each year |
| Typical label | Acc, thesaurierend, "C" | Dist, ausschüttend, "D" |
Three things that sound true and aren't
"Distributing ETFs pay me extra money." They don't. The fund's value drops by the payout.
"Accumulating ETFs are tax-free until I sell." Not quite. The Vorabpauschale can apply every year.
"Dist means a payout every month." Payout frequency differs by fund. Check the factsheet.
Questions about Acc and Dist
Can I switch from one class to the other?
Only by selling one and buying the other, which can trigger tax on your gains.
Which one suits a long-term savings plan?
Accumulating classes are often more convenient for long-term saving, because there's nothing to reinvest. 1 If you want regular cash flow, a distributing class may suit you better.
How to choose
Choose by what you want to do with the income: leave it working, or receive it. Don't pick a distributing fund for "extra" money, and don't pick an accumulating fund to avoid tax.
Check yourself
A distributing ETF pays you €100. What happens to the fund’s value that day?
Video lesson · In the makingAccumulating or distributing?
Official sources
- Verbraucherzentrale: ETF-Kauf: criteria for choosing an ETF
- § 16 InvStG: types of investment fund income
- § 20 InvStG: Teilfreistellung
- § 20 (9) EStG: Sparer-Pauschbetrag
- § 18 InvStG: Vorabpauschale
- § 19 InvStG: sale gains and earlier Vorabpauschalen
Last checked:
We explain how the German rules work in general. This isn't personal tax, legal or financial advice, and your bank, employer or tax office may treat your own case differently.